Shadow Donation

Published by Whole Whale

The register

PayPal Giving Fund

PayPal Giving Fund is a registered charity and donor-advised fund that receives donations made through partner programs it names, including eBay, Meta, GoFundMe, Deed and Twitch. Its help centre states that when a charity does not respond and a check is returned or refused, the donor has 14 days to pick another charity, and the fund remains the donee of record. It is named in the Alaska Attorney General's March 2026 suit.

Tier
Listed
Payouts via
PayPal Giving Fund (itself the donor-advised fund and donee of record)
Platform
www.paypal.com/us/webapps/mpp/givingfund/home
Checked
6 of 6 checks · 4 on dated evidence
Evidence
Bundle on file, captured 2026-09-18 · 19 hashed files · 2 screenshots

The checklist

What we have checked on PayPal Giving Fund, what we found, and what it rests on.

  1. Present, research only
    1. Off-domain Present, research only

    A Move for Hunger charity page was captured at paypal.com/us/fundraiser/charity/2262011 on 2026-07-21; the 2026-09-18 bundle did not capture a real charity page.

    Basis: Shadow Donation Directory, nonprofitnewsfeed.com
  2. Unresolved
    2. Auto-generated Unresolved

    Whether a charity can be listed before it enrolls is not answered by anything captured; the Alaska AG alleges pages were auto-generated from public data.

    Basis: Dated evidence bundle
  3. Unresolved
    3. No consent Unresolved

    Same open question as autoGenerated; the consent claim rests on the Alaska AG's allegation.

    Basis: Dated evidence bundle
  4. Present
    4. Takes gifts Present

    The fund states it receives donations through its partner programs and grants them to donors' recommended charities.

    Basis: Dated evidence bundle
  5. Present
    5. Intermediary Present

    The fund documents reassignment when a check is returned or refused, with a 14-day window for the donor to name another charity.

    Basis: Dated evidence bundle
  6. Present, research only
    6. Search-indexed Present, research only

    Page 4950 states the Move for Hunger charity page was Google-indexed on 2026-07-21; the 2026-09-18 evidence found charity pages not enumerated in the public sitemap, which limits sitemap exposure but does not show noindex.

    Basis: Shadow Donation Directory, nonprofitnewsfeed.com

Event log

Everything that has happened on the record, newest first.

  1. Capture

    Evidence bundle captured

    Whole Whale captured the sitemap index, help-centre articles and two browser screenshots by anonymous public GET.

    Source: PayPal Giving Fund evidence bundle
  2. Finding

    Reassignment rule and sitemap scope

    The fund's help centre documents reassignment of gifts a charity never collects; its 1,213-child sitemap index names no charity sitemap, and the parsed en-us child holds no /charity/ URLs.

    Source: PayPal Giving Fund investigation README
  3. Published

    NNF Shadow Donation Directory published

    WordPress page 4950 on nonprofitnewsfeed.com was published on 2026-07-23 with evidence dated 2026-07-21; this platform's row carries that date. The page revision history was not checked to confirm the row existed on day one.

    Source: NNF Shadow Donation Directory (page 4950)
  4. Capture

    Page 4950 capture

    Page 4950 dates its screenshots and sitemap column for this platform to 2026-07-21: the Move for Hunger charity page and a Google search.

    Source: NNF Shadow Donation Directory (page 4950)
  5. Regulatory

    Named in Alaska AG suit

    The Alaska Attorney General sued six platforms (GoFundMe, PayPal, Charity Navigator, JustGiving, Pledge and Network for Good), PayPal among them, alleging donation pages were created for charities without their knowledge or consent. The complaint text and case status have not been reviewed.

    Source: Alaska Department of Law press release, 2026-03-10
  6. Published

    Named in Whole Whale's source article

    Whole Whale's article "The Rise of Shadow Donation Pages", dated 2025-11-06, discusses PayPal Giving Fund in its current text. The saved copy carries later updates (one marked July 2026), so presence in the first version is not separately confirmed.

    Source: Whole Whale, The Rise of Shadow Donation Pages

If your organization is on PayPal Giving Fund

We have not verified a removal or claim route for PayPal Giving Fund yet. Search the platform for your legal name and EIN, and contact the platform directly.

Reply and corrections

PayPal Giving Fund can reply to anything on this page by writing to letstalk@wholewhale.com. We publish replies and log corrections with the date they were made.